SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread.

All Posts

1 2 3 4 5
>
Forum Index » Debate Forum
#1: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: Pincey , Location: offline Post Posted: Sat Aug 13, 2005 02:16 PM
    ----
This thread is for discussion about the debate. Are the Poncy Snape Lovah's kicking tail? Are you now utterly convinced that Snape is Evil, thanks to some powerful arguments? Discuss your thoughts here, and only here.
#2: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: pinknova , Location: Round the corner, down the lane and it's four doors up on the right! Post Posted: Sat Aug 13, 2005 07:36 PM
    ----
Go Clare, Go Clare, I've so been swayed into a Poncy Snape Lovah and I think we're going to kick butt. When I first joined Immy, I was all for 'Snape is evil' but I was young and STUPID, please forgive me, there is no question Snape is good.

I am also going to follow in the footsteps of the real debate and write in the colour of the team that I am backing. Poncy Snape Lovahs rule. Love
#3: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: Sarina , Location: Buried under a pile of books in a Massachusetts Barnes and Noble... please send help... or pie Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 02:43 AM
    ----
I'm supporting the "Good Snape" debaters but bravo to Incognito for sticking it out in there. Where are all the "Evil Snape" supporters...?
#4: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: Eruname , Location: Miami, FL Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 07:21 AM
    ----
Some of us have got lives. But just because we have lives doesn't mean we don't have arguments.

I'd recommend the debaters try to limit the lengths of their posts. There's no need to bang everything out in one shot and have nothing to do but repeat themselves afterwards.

*rubs forehead* I should not be doing this at this hour.
#5: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: siriusbfan , Location: Right here, generally. Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 07:58 AM
    ----
That's usually how these things go. You end up arguing about ten different trains of thought all at once, it's pretty unstoppable. Just remember that a lot of argument is not necessarily a strong argument.

*cheers the Poncy Snape lovahs* Beat them out with reanalysis!

-Siri
#6: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: kitenarie , Location: Try and find me, hahahah! Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 08:13 AM
    ----
Kit here, reporting for duty - unfortunately, I had to work today and apparently missed some very forceful and fast debate. Don't worry, I'm not abadoning ship.

Personally, I'm finding it a bit hard to follow the arguments of the Poncies, and it's not because they aren't well thought out and well debated, but that they are so bloody long that I've been sincerely losing focus. So I'd like to repeat Eru's request that we all try to keep our posts to a reasonable length and focus on making one or two really strong arguments.
#7: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: lunadiosa , Location: Washington State Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 09:09 AM
    ----
I'll put in a third vote for shorter posts! LOL Still everyone has had some good arguements - obviously a lot of work prior to the start of the debate. One thing I've noticed is that there seems to be some disagreement on what constitutes evil. Everyone seems to agree that Snape's behavior has been nasty - not much to debate there. The real question is whether he is loyal to Dumbledore or Lord Voldemort because either way he is a git!

I am also in the Snape/Lily shipper camp and I think that's the only reason he turned to DD. To me, that makes him a whole lot more on the "evil" side. Afterall, if LV had gone after the Longbottoms instead of the Potters, Snape would have done nothing! Nonetheless, I do think he was loyal to DD - and evil. ***I would put in a "confused" smiley here, but I can't get my stupid smilies to work****

Go...go...hmmm, not sure which side to cheer for....Go Everyone!

Nadi
#8: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: Mirunika , Location: Brussels, BE Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 04:36 PM
    ----
Uh, sorry guys, but it's a bit difficult to keep it short at times. I'll do my best.

*looks at all the snape=evil posts that were posted while she was away*

Oh well .. *dives in*
#9: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: Sarina , Location: Buried under a pile of books in a Massachusetts Barnes and Noble... please send help... or pie Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 06:32 PM
    ----
Sorry Eruname. I honestly didn't mean any harm. I was just wondering if the debate was still going on or not... *mumbles and blushes like a Weasley*
#10: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: bluebirdtexas , Location: Spinner's End Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 06:40 PM
    ----
[spam]

Haha, Sari... Eru may bark, but not bite. *huggles both*

[/spam]

The debate is really starting to flourish. Good arguments on both sides so far.

*shines her 'Poncey Snape Lovah' badge and goes to re-re-read the debate*
#11: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: Summerskystar , Location: Lost in my head in a daydream Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 08:40 PM
    ----
I am just stopping in to say, this is a great read. I am personally on the Snape is evil side. But win or lose, everyone has some great arguements.
#12: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: lunadiosa , Location: Washington State Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 09:57 PM
    ----
Miru - no no! You post as much as you like! It is tough trying to keep up with all of you (I'm just on page two now), but we'll get there. You guys have obviously been working hard - IT'S GREAT!

****SPAM Sari - your location is a riot! SPAM*****

Nadi
#13: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: Eruname , Location: Miami, FL Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 11:39 PM
    ----
Excuse me, but I can and will bite if I have reason to.
#14: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: Mirunika , Location: Brussels, BE Post Posted: Sun Aug 14, 2005 11:49 PM
    ----
Bring it on! *grin*

(I have ± three days of debating to go .. and am not afraid to use them.)
#15: Re: SNAPE: GOOD OR EVIL? The sidelines thread. Author: Eruname , Location: Miami, FL Post Posted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 12:48 AM
    ----
*nervous laugh* I was afraid I was a bit harsh. I hear what you are saying, Pince, and you are right. I was offended by the tone of the others, and..er..well, bit back I guess. I won't again! For my part, I will take your warning to heart. And I've edited my last post and removed all mean references to Poncys in general.

Alright, I really need to go for today. I've Math, English, French, and government homework left and only 4 more hours in the day!
Forum Index » Debate Forum

1 2 3 4 5
>
Page 1 of 5